Former Manchester United captain Roy Keane has stated he would not appoint Michael Carrick as the club’s permanent manager, despite the former midfielder’s strong start as interim boss, which includes wins over teams managed by Pep Guardiola and Mikel Arteta.
Keane made his remarks during a heated Sky Sports debate following United’s 3–2 comeback victory over Arsenal at the Emirates Stadium on Sunday. Carrick, 44, has enjoyed an impressive run in temporary charge, with victories over Manchester City, Arsenal, Unai Emery’s team, and Thomas Tuchel’s side, earning a perfect points return since taking over earlier this month.
When asked by Micah Richards if Carrick should be considered for the role full-time, Keane dismissed the idea. “No, you’re being silly,” he said. “He’s had two great performances, but anybody can win two games. Even if they finish fourth, I still wouldn’t be convinced he’s the man. They need a bigger, more experienced manager.”
Keane added that even a flawless run of results wouldn’t change his view. “If United win every game from now until the end of the season, I still wouldn’t give him the job,” he said. “Carrick could win every game, and of course he’s enjoying it—but winning matches is what makes management enjoyable.”
United’s victory over Arsenal featured a dramatic late comeback, with Patrick Dorgu and Matheus Cunha scoring after Bryan Mbeumo had equalised, following a prior win over Manchester City that has strengthened United’s league position.
Keane questioned whether Carrick could handle the long-term demands of managing a club of United’s stature. “You want a manager who can get United winning league titles. Are we seriously saying Carrick can do that based on the last two weeks? I don’t believe he’s the man to bring United back to the top.”
Former Arsenal captain Patrick Vieira disagreed, arguing that Carrick deserved a chance, pointing to young, inexperienced managers who have thrived at top clubs. Keane countered, noting that while some succeed, many do not.
Gary Neville offered a balanced view, praising Carrick for restoring belief in the team, but suggesting the club should still appoint an elite, experienced coach at season’s end. Keane continued to challenge Neville’s stance during the debate.
Carrick is expected to remain interim manager until the end of the season, following the model used during Ralf Rangnick’s tenure, while Manchester United search for a permanent head coach.
